Reason Magazine

Site Search

Because It Feels So Good When You Stop

This is not your father's asphyxiation game:

While asphyxiation games have been around for many years, a series of locally publicized deaths around the country over the last few years, coupled with a realization that teenagers are seeing the game on Internet sites like YouTube, and playing it in more threatening variations—more often, like Levi, alone with a rope—are sparking a vigorous and open discussion in schools and among parents' groups, summer camp administrators and doctors....

A group called the Dylan Blake Foundation, founded by a parent who lost an 11-year-old son in 2005, said there were at least 40 deaths and 5 serious injuries from the game in the United States alone last year.

But the exact number remains uncertain because there has been little real research, health professionals say, and because medical examiners have been quick in the past to rule suicide. Some adults might also dismiss the game as the slumber party goof it was in years past, when constriction to the point of death was virtually unheard of....

"Asphyxiation games have been with us for generations, but what makes the current generation's execution of this game different is that more kids are willing to play it alone," said Dr. Thomas Andrew, the chief medical examiner in New Hampshire.

If seeing choking for kicks on YouTube stimulates interest in the practice, what impact will "antichoking game presentations" such as those described in the article have on impressionable young minds? Well, at least they're not smoking pot.

Send this article to:

« Free to Choose Rudy | Main | John Tierney on William Hurwitz »

Comments to "Because It Feels So Good When You Stop":

JohnD | March 28, 2007, 12:04pm | #

And this years "Darwin Award" goes to....

Warren | March 28, 2007, 12:05pm | #

...there were at least 40 deaths and 5 serious injuries

Jeebus H Christ on a pogo stick. Can't we make a rule that you aren't allowed to start a "for the children" panic with less than 10,000 deaths per year?

Timothy | March 28, 2007, 12:05pm | #

So 40 deaths a year, that's, what one in a million? According to the census, there are 36.4 million elementary children, and 16.8 million folks between 14 and 17, so at worst you're looking at a one in a million occurrence. That is, hardly worth worrying about.

Lost_In_Translation | March 28, 2007, 12:06pm | #

JohnD beat me to it.

Frankly, people that accidently kill themselves by playing an ashphyxiation game deserve to die, the stupid bastards. Better that they cease to pollute the gene pool.

Pro Libertate | March 28, 2007, 12:10pm | #

Well, it's easy to forget how dumb kids can be, especially when their stupider peers are involved. I'm not quite willing to say that warning kids about something dangerous (whether generally lethal or not) is a bad idea. Legislation or a course curriculum dedicated to this issue would be another matter, of course.

de stijl | March 28, 2007, 12:15pm | #

Kids still do this? Don't they have an XBox 360 or a Wii? Why do their parents hate them so to deny them these gaming pleasures. I blame these thoughtless, negligent parents.

If I were the parent of a tween, I would recommend a rainbow party over an asphyxiation party. Huffing parties during January also brighten up the darkest days of the year.

John | March 28, 2007, 12:24pm | #

At least they aren't sticking leeches on themselves.

Hugh Akston | March 28, 2007, 12:27pm | #

"what impact will "antichoking game presentations" such as those described in the article have on impressionable young minds?"

In the alternate universe that public health officials inhabit, there is no youthful behavior that cannot be discouraged by a stern lecture in a classroom setting. You know, because kids respect the authority of their teachers and everything.

Warren | March 28, 2007, 12:27pm | #

Huffing parties during January also brighten up the darkest days of the year.

HA!

Mr. Nice Guy | March 28, 2007, 12:36pm | #

Omigod! If you, like, do a bong hit (and hold it), and then have a chick choke you, and have another chick do.. something to you, and at the same time, you perform a certain bodily function.. you get SO HIGH!

That's what happend to that guy from INXS.

Will Allen | March 28, 2007, 12:49pm | #

TMI, Nice Guy.

highnumber | March 28, 2007, 12:57pm | #

Ugh, I played the pass-out game. Drug-free youth still got high.

signed,
No longer nailed to the X.

JimmyDaGeek | March 28, 2007, 1:08pm | #

If I were a parent, I'd tell my kid(s), "If you play this 'game' and don't die, you better hope that I don't get wind of it. Because if I do, I'm going to beat the shit out of you and you'll wish that you had died."

Number 6 | March 28, 2007, 1:32pm | #

This is one of those perennial media-driven panics. I remember Oprah doing a special on the same thing when I was 12 or so. (My initial thought was 'What the hell is wrong with these morons?') When ratings dip, it's oh-so-easy to reach into the file labeled 'stories dealing with teens, sex, and death.' Given our national prurient interest in the sex lives of adolescents and the desire of some folks to have something to panic about, it's a can't miss story.

JimmyDaGeek | March 28, 2007, 1:33pm | #

Passim,

Unfortunately, it seems as if your type of parenting is going by the wayside. Too many parents are too selfish and self-centered to really, truly care about what goes on in the lives of their children.

ChrisO | March 28, 2007, 1:36pm | #

Maybe I'm sheltered, but I never heard of kids doing this. Autoerotic asphyxiation--*that* I've heard of and even met someone who later died from it.

I agree about the Darwin Award aspect of this.

Courtney | March 28, 2007, 1:39pm | #

This sounds oddly familiar to the Chubby Bunny epidemic of '05!

SugarFree | March 28, 2007, 1:48pm | #

My favorite pro-legalization argument (when I'm not talking to a stone cold moron) is to point out that small children who can barely walk will spin around and around until they fall down dizzy. We seek to alter our consciousness before we can even grasp its crudest distinctions. We will never wipe out drugs.

These kids are just doing what all of the rest of us do, they just don't have our fancy tools (pot, wine, Wellbutrin, sex, etc.) I vote we take it easy on them. Think about how many times as a child or a teenager you could have died if some little thing (like squeezing too long) had been different. I should have died maybe... thirty times?

(Disclaimer: I'm really not nagging you guys to be nice. I thought the crying fat Santorum girl was hilarious...)

Eric the .5b | March 28, 2007, 2:05pm | #

Kids still do this? Don't they have an XBox 360 or a Wii?
Or internet porn and their dominant hands?

Papist Avenger | March 28, 2007, 2:07pm | #

highnumber,

He's nailed to the X with every rainbow party, asphyxiation game, and plastic bag thrown in the street, not to mention all the other crimes committed by our wicked kind.

Doctor Duck | March 28, 2007, 3:23pm | #

If this is really a one in a million occurrence, we shouldn't make a big deal of it with kids 'cause it would just make even more morons aware of it as an option.

Freaking out Mr. Mulder | March 28, 2007, 3:27pm | #

Autoerotic asphyxiation is a horrible way to die.

JW | March 28, 2007, 3:47pm | #

I'm not a Victorian! But am I really the only guy my age--other than Mormons--who manages to keep an eye on his kids?

Nope. Even though my youngins' aren't that old yet, my favorite game is Silent Dad of Death.

When I know they are up to no good, I walk very quietly to the scene of the crime and just stand there until they notice me. Sometimes it takes a minute or so.

The look of total shock on their faces is worth everything.

Frankly, people that accidently kill themselves by playing an ashphyxiation game deserve to die, the stupid bastards. Better that they cease to pollute the gene pool.

I take it then, you are not a parent and have forgotten just how unbeliveably stupid and impressionable 11-year old boys can be.

Not that I think we need to "do something" about this extremely rare act, but you can always spot the childless males in a crowd.

Tseren | March 28, 2007, 4:35pm | #

Fantastic, another foundation to stop people from being stupid.

Hey, I have two kids and my life would just about be over if anything happened to them. But you know what, I'd be more pissed that they didn't have the foresight to see that perhaps they might die doing this. Cuz if I found out they were playing this game and didn't die, I'd kill them.

Rex Rhino | March 28, 2007, 5:30pm | #

Did anyone else see the urban-myth style "report" on CNN about the evil meth dealers turning meth into sugary candy to addict the children... and lots of factless fearmongering about it!

While you can get a few people worked up about suffocation games, there is no clear target (i.e. a drug dealer) that we can vilify. The meth candy is going to be this year's Rainbow Party panic! Trust me!

The Wine Commonsewer | March 28, 2007, 6:39pm | #

Uh, couldn't a chick choke while getting too enthusiastic with the rainbow?

The Wine Commonsewer | March 28, 2007, 6:43pm | #

JimmyDa....Me and you man.

Mrs TWC and I both work at home. The House Blond is getting locked in the basement the minute puberty hits and her brother is going to be chained to his desk.

Seriously, we keep them busy because BUSY HANDS ARE HAPPY HANDS.

The Wine Commonsewer | March 28, 2007, 6:45pm | #

And, That boy is NEVER getting a driver license, Jesus Chrysler, I swear he hasn't got any sense at all. :-)

Another thing too, we're straight up about stuff. I told him all about the glue sniffer I knew in grade school that ended up coughing up his lungs and died on the floor in the garage. Don't sniff that stuff, son, it will make you high but it's just as likely to give you brain damage and you ain't got any brain cells to spare.

The Wine Commonsewer | March 28, 2007, 6:50pm | #

I take it then, you are not a parent and have forgotten just how unbeliveably stupid and impressionable 11-year old boys can be.

And Girls.

Yesterday, I'm playing handball with my 10 year old boy and I hear the House Blonde holler lookit me daddy. She's 8.

I turn around and she has climbed the basketball pole and stuck her head up through the rim and has the net wrapped around her head. My eyes got big as saucers.

Fortunately, no harm no foul, but I told her right quick that if she did that when nobody was around and slipped, lost her grip, whatever, she'd likely as not hang herself. And that's the connection to the thread, accidental hanging.

Courtney | March 28, 2007, 9:51pm | #

TWC- I do believe an eight year old almost hanging her self is much different from a teenager intentionally cutting off the oxygen to his brain. I say go for it buddy, one less i have to worry about collecting "citizen" assistance.